replace magic controller strings with enums

automatic detected controller update in GameInfoDialog & StellaSettingsDialog

src/common/PJoystickHandler.cxx

@@ -321,29 +321,33 @@ void PhysicalJoystickHandler::setDefaultMapping(Event::Type event, EventMode mod
 }
 
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-void PhysicalJoystickHandler::defineControllerMappings(const string& controllerName, Controller::Jack port)
+void PhysicalJoystickHandler::defineControllerMappings(const Controller::Type type, Controller::Jack port)
 {
   // determine controller events to use
-  if ((controllerName == "KEYBOARD") || (controllerName == "KEYPAD"))
+  switch(type)
   {
+    case Controller::Type::Keyboard:
       if(port == Controller::Jack::Left)
         myLeftMode = EventMode::kKeypadMode;
       else
         myRightMode = EventMode::kKeypadMode;
-  }
+      break;
-  else if (BSPF::startsWithIgnoreCase(controllerName, "PADDLES"))
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::Paddles:
+    case Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxDr:
+    case Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxis:
       if(port == Controller::Jack::Left)
         myLeftMode = EventMode::kPaddlesMode;
       else
         myRightMode = EventMode::kPaddlesMode;
-  }
+      break;
-  else if (controllerName == "CM")
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::CompuMate:
       myLeftMode = myRightMode = EventMode::kCompuMateMode;
-  }
+      break;
-  else
+
-  {
+    default:
+      // let's use joystick then
       if(port == Controller::Jack::Left)
         myLeftMode = EventMode::kJoystickMode;
       else

src/common/PJoystickHandler.hxx

@@ -71,7 +71,7 @@ class PhysicalJoystickHandler
     void setDefaultMapping(Event::Type type, EventMode mode);
 
     /** define mappings for current controllers */
-    void defineControllerMappings(const string& controllerName, Controller::Jack port);
+    void defineControllerMappings(const Controller::Type type, Controller::Jack port);
     /** enable mappings for emulation mode */
     void enableEmulationMappings();
 

src/common/PKeyboardHandler.cxx

@@ -139,29 +139,33 @@ void PhysicalKeyboardHandler::setDefaultMapping(Event::Type event, EventMode mod
 }
 
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-void PhysicalKeyboardHandler::defineControllerMappings(const string& controllerName, Controller::Jack port)
+void PhysicalKeyboardHandler::defineControllerMappings(const Controller::Type type, Controller::Jack port)
 {
   // determine controller events to use
-  if ((controllerName == "KEYBOARD") || (controllerName == "KEYPAD"))
+  switch(type)
   {
+    case Controller::Type::Keyboard:
       if(port == Controller::Jack::Left)
         myLeftMode = EventMode::kKeypadMode;
       else
         myRightMode = EventMode::kKeypadMode;
-  }
+      break;
-  else if (BSPF::startsWithIgnoreCase(controllerName, "PADDLES"))
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::Paddles:
+    case Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxDr:
+    case Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxis:
       if(port == Controller::Jack::Left)
         myLeftMode = EventMode::kPaddlesMode;
       else
         myRightMode = EventMode::kPaddlesMode;
-  }
+      break;
-  else if (controllerName == "CM")
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::CompuMate:
       myLeftMode = myRightMode = EventMode::kCompuMateMode;
-  }
+      break;
-  else
+
-  {
+    default:
+      // let's use joystick then
       if(port == Controller::Jack::Left)
         myLeftMode = EventMode::kJoystickMode;
       else

src/common/PKeyboardHandler.hxx

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ class PhysicalKeyboardHandler
     void setDefaultMapping(Event::Type type, EventMode mode, bool updateDefaults = false);
 
     /** define mappings for current controllers */
-    void defineControllerMappings(const string& controllerName, Controller::Jack port);
+    void defineControllerMappings(const Controller::Type type, Controller::Jack port);
     /** enable mappings for emulation mode */
     void enableEmulationMappings();
 

src/emucore/Console.cxx

@@ -801,14 +801,14 @@ void Console::setControllers(const string& romMd5)
 
     myLeftControl  = std::move(myCMHandler->leftController());
     myRightControl = std::move(myCMHandler->rightController());
-    myOSystem.eventHandler().defineKeyControllerMappings("CM", Controller::Jack::Left);
+    myOSystem.eventHandler().defineKeyControllerMappings(Controller::Type::CompuMate, Controller::Jack::Left);
-    myOSystem.eventHandler().defineJoyControllerMappings("CM", Controller::Jack::Left);
+    myOSystem.eventHandler().defineJoyControllerMappings(Controller::Type::CompuMate, Controller::Jack::Left);
   }
   else
   {
     // Setup the controllers based on properties
-    string left = myProperties.get(PropType::Controller_Left);
+    Controller::Type leftType = Controller::getType(myProperties.get(PropType::Controller_Left));
-    string right = myProperties.get(PropType::Controller_Right);
+    Controller::Type rightType = Controller::getType(myProperties.get(PropType::Controller_Right));
     uInt32 size = 0;
     const uInt8* image = myCart->getImage(size);
     const bool swappedPorts = myProperties.get(PropType::Console_SwapPorts) == "YES";
@@ -816,14 +816,14 @@ void Console::setControllers(const string& romMd5)
     // Try to detect controllers
     if(image != nullptr || size != 0)
     {
-      left = ControllerDetector::detectType(image, size, left,
+      leftType = ControllerDetector::detectType(image, size, leftType,
           !swappedPorts ? Controller::Jack::Left : Controller::Jack::Right, myOSystem.settings());
-      right = ControllerDetector::detectType(image, size, right,
+      rightType = ControllerDetector::detectType(image, size, rightType,
           !swappedPorts ? Controller::Jack::Right : Controller::Jack::Left, myOSystem.settings());
     }
 
-    unique_ptr<Controller> leftC = getControllerPort(left, Controller::Jack::Left, romMd5),
+    unique_ptr<Controller> leftC = getControllerPort(leftType, Controller::Jack::Left, romMd5),
-      rightC = getControllerPort(right, Controller::Jack::Right, romMd5);
+      rightC = getControllerPort(rightType, Controller::Jack::Right, romMd5);
 
     // Swap the ports if necessary
     if(!swappedPorts)
@@ -848,56 +848,56 @@ void Console::setControllers(const string& romMd5)
 }
 
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-unique_ptr<Controller> Console::getControllerPort(const string& controllerName,
+unique_ptr<Controller> Console::getControllerPort(const Controller::Type type,
-                                                  Controller::Jack port, const string& romMd5)
+                                                  const Controller::Jack port, const string& romMd5)
 {
   unique_ptr<Controller> controller;
 
-  myOSystem.eventHandler().defineKeyControllerMappings(controllerName, port);
+  myOSystem.eventHandler().defineKeyControllerMappings(type, port);
-  myOSystem.eventHandler().defineJoyControllerMappings(controllerName, port);
+  myOSystem.eventHandler().defineJoyControllerMappings(type, port);
 
-  if(controllerName == "JOYSTICK")
+  switch(type)
-  {
-    // always create because it may have been changed by user dialog
-    controller = make_unique<Joystick>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
-  else if(controllerName == "BOOSTERGRIP")
   {
+    case Controller::Type::BoosterGrip:
       controller = make_unique<BoosterGrip>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if(controllerName == "DRIVING")
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::Driving:
       controller = make_unique<Driving>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if((controllerName == "KEYBOARD") || (controllerName == "KEYPAD"))
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::Keyboard:
       controller = make_unique<Keyboard>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if(BSPF::startsWithIgnoreCase(controllerName, "PADDLES"))
+
+    case Controller::Type::Paddles:
+    case Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxis:
+    case Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxDr:
     {
       // Also check if we should swap the paddles plugged into a jack
       bool swapPaddles = myProperties.get(PropType::Controller_SwapPaddles) == "YES";
       bool swapAxis = false, swapDir = false;
-    if(controllerName == "PADDLES_IAXIS")
+      if(type == Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxis)
         swapAxis = true;
-    else if(controllerName == "PADDLES_IAXDR")
+      else if(type == Controller::Type::PaddlesIAxDr)
         swapAxis = swapDir = true;
       controller = make_unique<Paddles>(port, myEvent, *mySystem,
                                         swapPaddles, swapAxis, swapDir);
+      break;
     }
-  else if(controllerName == "AMIGAMOUSE")
+    case Controller::Type::AmigaMouse:
-  {
       controller = make_unique<AmigaMouse>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if(controllerName == "ATARIMOUSE")
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::AtariMouse:
       controller = make_unique<AtariMouse>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if(controllerName == "TRAKBALL")
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::TrakBall:
       controller = make_unique<TrakBall>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if(controllerName == "ATARIVOX")
+
+    case Controller::Type::AtariVox:
     {
       const string& nvramfile = myOSystem.nvramDir() + "atarivox_eeprom.dat";
       Controller::onMessageCallback callback = [&os = myOSystem](const string& msg) {
@@ -907,8 +907,9 @@ unique_ptr<Controller> Console::getControllerPort(const string& controllerName,
       };
       controller = make_unique<AtariVox>(port, myEvent, *mySystem,
           myOSystem.settings().getString("avoxport"), nvramfile, callback);
+      break;
     }
-  else if(controllerName == "SAVEKEY")
+    case Controller::Type::SaveKey:
     {
       const string& nvramfile = myOSystem.nvramDir() + "savekey_eeprom.dat";
       Controller::onMessageCallback callback = [&os = myOSystem](const string& msg) {
@@ -917,21 +918,25 @@ unique_ptr<Controller> Console::getControllerPort(const string& controllerName,
           os.frameBuffer().showMessage(msg);
       };
       controller = make_unique<SaveKey>(port, myEvent, *mySystem, nvramfile, callback);
+      break;
     }
-  else if(controllerName == "GENESIS")
+    case Controller::Type::Genesis:
-  {
       controller = make_unique<Genesis>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if(controllerName == "KIDVID")
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::KidVid:
       controller = make_unique<KidVid>(port, myEvent, *mySystem, romMd5);
-  }
+      break;
-  else if(controllerName == "MINDLINK")
+
-  {
+    case Controller::Type::MindLink:
       controller = make_unique<MindLink>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
-  }
+      break;
-  else  // What else can we do?
+
+    default:
+      // What else can we do?
+      // always create because it may have been changed by user dialog
       controller = make_unique<Joystick>(port, myEvent, *mySystem);
+  }
 
   return controller;
 }

src/emucore/Console.hxx

@@ -339,8 +339,8 @@ class Console : public Serializable, public ConsoleIO
     /**
       Selects the left or right controller depending on ROM properties
     */
-    unique_ptr<Controller> getControllerPort(const string& controllerName,
+    unique_ptr<Controller> getControllerPort(const Controller::Type type,
-                                             Controller::Jack port, const string& romMd5);
+                                             const Controller::Jack port, const string& romMd5);
 
     /**
       Loads a user-defined palette file (from OSystem::paletteFile), filling the

src/emucore/Control.cxx

@@ -103,3 +103,48 @@ bool Controller::load(Serializer& in)
   }
   return true;
 }
+
+// - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
+string Controller::getName(const Type type)
+{
+  string NAMES[int(Controller::Type::LastType)] =
+  {
+    "Unknown",
+    "AmigaMouse", "AtariMouse", "AtariVox", "BoosterGrip", "CompuMate",
+    "Driving", "Sega Genesis", "Joystick", "Keyboard", "KidVid", "MindLink",
+    "Paddles", "Paddles_IAxis", "Paddles_IAxDr", "SaveKey", "TrakBall"
+  };
+
+  return NAMES[int(type)];
+}
+
+// - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
+string Controller::getPropName(const Type type)
+{
+  string PROP_NAMES[int(Controller::Type::LastType)] =
+  {
+    "AUTO",
+    "AMIGAMOUSE", "ATARIMOUSE", "ATARIVOX", "BOOSTERGRIP", "COMPUMATE",
+    "DRIVING", "GENESIS", "JOYSTICK", "KEYBOARD", "KIDVID", "MINDLINK",
+    "PADDLES", "PADDLES_IAXIS", "PADDLES_IAXDR", "SAVEKEY", "TRAKBALL"
+  };
+
+  return PROP_NAMES[int(type)];
+}
+
+// - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
+Controller::Type Controller::getType(const string& propName)
+{
+  for(int i = 0; i < static_cast<int>(Type::LastType); ++i)
+  {
+    if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(propName, getPropName(Type(i))))
+    {
+      return Type(i);
+    }
+  }
+  // special case
+  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(propName, "KEYPAD"))
+    return Type::Keyboard;
+
+  return Type::Unknown;
+}

src/emucore/Control.hxx

@@ -90,9 +90,11 @@ class Controller : public Serializable
     */
     enum class Type
     {
+      Unknown,
       AmigaMouse, AtariMouse, AtariVox, BoosterGrip, CompuMate,
       Driving, Genesis, Joystick, Keyboard, KidVid, MindLink,
-      Paddles, SaveKey, TrakBall
+      Paddles, PaddlesIAxis, PaddlesIAxDr, SaveKey, TrakBall,
+      LastType
     };
 
     /**
@@ -254,6 +256,21 @@ class Controller : public Serializable
       myOnAnalogPinUpdateCallback = callback;
     }
 
+    /**
+      Returns the display name of the given controller type
+    */
+    static string getName(const Type type);
+
+    /**
+      Returns the property name of the given controller type
+    */
+    static string getPropName(const Type type);
+
+    /**
+      Returns the controller type of the given property name
+    */
+    static Type getType(const string& propName);
+
   public:
     /// Constant which represents maximum resistance for analog pins
     static constexpr Int32 MAX_RESISTANCE = 0x7FFFFFFF;

src/emucore/ControllerDetector.cxx

@@ -17,26 +17,27 @@
 //============================================================================
 
 #include "Settings.hxx"
+#include "Logger.hxx"
 
 #include "ControllerDetector.hxx"
 
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-string ControllerDetector::detectType(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
+Controller::Type ControllerDetector::detectType(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
-                                      const string& controller, const Controller::Jack port,
+                                                const Controller::Type type, const Controller::Jack port,
                                                 const Settings& settings)
 {
-  string type(controller);
+  if(type == Controller::Type::Unknown || settings.getBool("rominfo"))
-
-  if(type == "AUTO" || settings.getBool("rominfo"))
   {
-    string detectedType = autodetectPort(image, size, port, settings);
+    Controller::Type detectedType = autodetectPort(image, size, port, settings);
 
-    if(type != "AUTO" && type != detectedType)
+    if(type != Controller::Type::Unknown && type != detectedType)
     {
       cerr << "Controller auto-detection not consistent: "
-        << type << ", " << detectedType << endl;
+        << Controller::getName(type) << ", " << Controller::getName(detectedType) << endl;
     }
-    type = detectedType;
+    Logger::debug(Controller::getName(detectedType) + " detected for " +
+      (port == Controller::Jack::Left ? "left" : "right") + " port");
+    return detectedType;
   }
 
   return type;
@@ -44,38 +45,39 @@ string ControllerDetector::detectType(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
 
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
 string ControllerDetector::detectName(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
-                                      const string& controller, const Controller::Jack port,
+                                      const Controller::Type controller, const Controller::Jack port,
                                       const Settings& settings)
 {
-  return getControllerName(detectType(image, size, controller, port, settings));
+  return Controller::getName(detectType(image, size, controller, port, settings));
 }
 
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-string ControllerDetector::autodetectPort(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
+Controller::Type ControllerDetector::autodetectPort(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
                                                     Controller::Jack port, const Settings& settings)
 {
   // default type joystick
-  string type = "JOYSTICK"; // TODO: remove magic strings
+  Controller::Type type = Controller::Type::Joystick;
 
   if(isProbablySaveKey(image, size, port))
-    type = "SAVEKEY";
+    type = Controller::Type::SaveKey;
   else if(usesJoystickButton(image, size, port))
   {
     if(isProbablyTrakBall(image, size))
-      type = "TRAKBALL";
+      type = Controller::Type::TrakBall;
     else if(isProbablyAtariMouse(image, size))
-      type = "ATARIMOUSE";
+      type = Controller::Type::AmigaMouse;
     else if(isProbablyAmigaMouse(image, size))
-      type = "AMIGAMOUSE";
+      type = Controller::Type::AmigaMouse;
     else if(usesKeyboard(image, size, port))
-      type = "KEYBOARD";
+      type = Controller::Type::Keyboard;
     else if(usesGenesisButton(image, size, port))
-      type = "GENESIS";
+
+      type = Controller::Type::Genesis;
   }
   else
   {
     if(usesPaddle(image, size, port, settings))
-      type = "PADDLES";
+      type = Controller::Type::Paddles;
   }
   // TODO: BOOSTERGRIP, DRIVING, MINDLINK, ATARIVOX, KIDVID
   // not detectable: PADDLES_IAXIS, PADDLES_IAXDR
@@ -638,44 +640,3 @@ bool ControllerDetector::isProbablySaveKey(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size, Cont
 
   return false;
 }
-
-// - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-const string ControllerDetector::getControllerName(const string& controller)
-{
-  // auto detected:
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "JOYSTICK"))
-    return "Joystick";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "SAVEKEY"))
-    return "SaveKey";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "TRAKBALL"))
-    return "TrakBall";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "ATARIMOUSE"))
-    return "AtariMouse";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "AMIGAMOUSE"))
-    return "AmigaMouse";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "KEYBOARD"))
-    return "Keyboard";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "GENESIS"))
-    return "Sega Genesis";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "PADDLES"))
-    return "Paddles";
-  // not auto detected:
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "BOOSTERGRIP"))
-    return "BoosterGrip";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "DRIVING"))
-    return "Driving";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "MINDLINK"))
-    return "MindLink";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "ATARIVOX"))
-    return "AtariVox";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "PADDLES_IAXIS"))
-    return "Paddles IAxis";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "PADDLES_IAXDR"))
-    return "Paddles IAxDr";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "COMPUMATE"))
-    return "CompuMate";
-  if(BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(controller, "KIDVID"))
-    return "KidVid";
-
-  return controller;
-}

src/emucore/ControllerDetector.hxx

@@ -15,7 +15,6 @@
 // this file, and for a DISCLAIMER OF ALL WARRANTIES.
 //============================================================================
 
-
 #ifndef CONTROLLER_DETECTOR_HXX
 #define CONTROLLER_DETECTOR_HXX
 
@@ -40,8 +39,8 @@ class ControllerDetector
       @param settings   A reference to the various settings (read-only)
       @return   The detected controller type
     */
-    static string detectType(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
+    static Controller::Type detectType(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
-                             const string& controller, const Controller::Jack port,
+                                       const Controller::Type controller, const Controller::Jack port,
                                        const Settings& settings);
 
     /**
@@ -50,25 +49,16 @@ class ControllerDetector
 
       @param image      A pointer to the ROM image
       @param size       The size of the ROM image
-      @param controller The provided controller type of the ROM image
+      @param type       The provided controller type of the ROM image
       @param port       The port to be checked
       @param settings   A reference to the various settings (read-only)
 
       @return   The (detected) controller name
     */
     static string detectName(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size,
-                             const string& controller, const Controller::Jack port,
+                             const Controller::Type type, const Controller::Jack port,
                              const Settings& settings);
 
-    /**
-      Returns a nicer formatted name for the given controller.
-
-      @param controller The provided controller type of the ROM image
-
-      @return   The controller name
-    */
-    static const string getControllerName(const string& controller);
-
   private:
     /**
       Detects the controller type at the given port.
@@ -80,7 +70,7 @@ class ControllerDetector
 
       @return   The detected controller type
     */
-    static string autodetectPort(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size, Controller::Jack port,
+    static Controller::Type autodetectPort(const uInt8* image, uInt32 size, Controller::Jack port,
                                            const Settings& settings);
 
     /**

src/emucore/EventHandler.hxx

@@ -194,8 +194,8 @@ class EventHandler
     /**
       Enable controller specific keyboard event mappings.
     */
-    void defineKeyControllerMappings(const string& controllerName, Controller::Jack port) {
+    void defineKeyControllerMappings(const Controller::Type type, Controller::Jack port) {
-      myPKeyHandler->defineControllerMappings(controllerName, port);
+      myPKeyHandler->defineControllerMappings(type, port);
     }
 
     /**
@@ -245,8 +245,8 @@ class EventHandler
     /**
       Enable controller specific keyboard event mappings.
     */
-    void defineJoyControllerMappings(const string& controllerName, Controller::Jack port) {
+    void defineJoyControllerMappings(const Controller::Type type, Controller::Jack port) {
-      myPJoyHandler->defineControllerMappings(controllerName, port);
+      myPJoyHandler->defineControllerMappings(type, port);
     }
 
     /**

src/gui/GameInfoDialog.cxx

@@ -462,50 +462,10 @@ void GameInfoDialog::loadConsoleProperties(const Properties& props)
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
 void GameInfoDialog::loadControllerProperties(const Properties& props)
 {
-  bool swapPorts = props.get(PropType::Console_SwapPorts) == "YES";
-  bool autoDetect = false;
-  ByteBuffer image;
-  string md5 = props.get(PropType::Cart_MD5);
-  uInt32 size = 0;
-
-  // try to load the image for auto detection
-  if(!instance().hasConsole())
-  {
-    const FilesystemNode& node = FilesystemNode(instance().launcher().selectedRom());
-
-    autoDetect = node.exists() && !node.isDirectory() && (image = instance().openROM(node, md5, size)) != nullptr;
-  }
-  string label = "";
   string controller = props.get(PropType::Controller_Left);
-
   myLeftPort->setSelected(controller, "AUTO");
-  if(myLeftPort->getSelectedTag().toString() == "AUTO")
-  {
-    if(instance().hasConsole())
-      label = (!swapPorts ? instance().console().leftController().name()
-               : instance().console().rightController().name()) + " detected";
-    else if(autoDetect)
-      label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, controller,
-                                             !swapPorts ? Controller::Jack::Left : Controller::Jack::Right,
-                                             instance().settings()) + " detected";
-  }
-  myLeftPortDetected->setLabel(label);
-
-  label = "";
   controller = props.get(PropType::Controller_Right);
-
   myRightPort->setSelected(controller, "AUTO");
-  if(myRightPort->getSelectedTag().toString() == "AUTO")
-  {
-    if(instance().hasConsole())
-      label = (!swapPorts ? instance().console().rightController().name()
-               : instance().console().leftController().name()) + " detected";
-    else if(autoDetect)
-      label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, controller,
-                                             !swapPorts ? Controller::Jack::Right : Controller::Jack::Left,
-                                             instance().settings()) + " detected";
-  }
-  myRightPortDetected->setLabel(label);
 
   mySwapPorts->setState(props.get(PropType::Console_SwapPorts) == "YES");
   mySwapPaddles->setState(props.get(PropType::Controller_SwapPaddles) == "YES");
@@ -650,6 +610,49 @@ void GameInfoDialog::setDefaults()
 // - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
 void GameInfoDialog::updateControllerStates()
 {
+  bool swapPorts = mySwapPorts->getState();
+  bool autoDetect = false;
+  ByteBuffer image;
+  string md5 = myGameProperties.get(PropType::Cart_MD5);
+  uInt32 size = 0;
+
+  // try to load the image for auto detection
+  if(!instance().hasConsole())
+  {
+    const FilesystemNode& node = FilesystemNode(instance().launcher().selectedRom());
+
+    autoDetect = node.exists() && !node.isDirectory() && (image = instance().openROM(node, md5, size)) != nullptr;
+  }
+  string label = "";
+  Controller::Type type = Controller::getType(myLeftPort->getSelectedTag().toString());
+
+  if(type == Controller::Type::Unknown)
+  {
+    if(instance().hasConsole())
+      label = (!swapPorts ? instance().console().leftController().name()
+               : instance().console().rightController().name()) + " detected";
+    else if(autoDetect)
+      label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, type,
+                                             !swapPorts ? Controller::Jack::Left : Controller::Jack::Right,
+                                             instance().settings()) + " detected";
+  }
+  myLeftPortDetected->setLabel(label);
+
+  label = "";
+  type = Controller::getType(myRightPort->getSelectedTag().toString());
+
+  if(type == Controller::Type::Unknown)
+  {
+    if(instance().hasConsole())
+      label = (!swapPorts ? instance().console().rightController().name()
+               : instance().console().leftController().name()) + " detected";
+    else if(autoDetect)
+      label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, type,
+                                             !swapPorts ? Controller::Jack::Right : Controller::Jack::Left,
+                                             instance().settings()) + " detected";
+  }
+  myRightPortDetected->setLabel(label);
+
   const string& contrLeft = myLeftPort->getSelectedTag().toString();
   const string& contrRight = myRightPort->getSelectedTag().toString();
   bool enableEEEraseButton = false;
@@ -667,9 +670,6 @@ void GameInfoDialog::updateControllerStates()
     const Controller& lport = instance().console().leftController();
     const Controller& rport = instance().console().rightController();
 
-    enableSwapPaddles |= BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(instance().console().leftController().name(), "Paddles");
-    enableSwapPaddles |= BSPF::equalsIgnoreCase(instance().console().rightController().name(), "Paddles");
-
     // we only enable the button if we have a valid previous and new controller.
     bool enableBtnForLeft =
       (contrLeft == "AUTO" || contrLeft == "SAVEKEY" || contrLeft == "ATARIVOX") &&
@@ -728,7 +728,7 @@ void GameInfoDialog::handleCommand(CommandSender* sender, int cmd,
       break;
 
     case TabWidget::kTabChangedCmd:
-      if(data == 2)  // 'Controller' tab selected
+      if(data == 2)  // 'Controllers' tab selected
         updateControllerStates();
 
       // The underlying dialog still needs access to this command

src/gui/RomInfoWidget.cxx

@@ -136,6 +136,8 @@ void RomInfoWidget::parseProperties(const FilesystemNode& node)
   // Load the image for controller auto detection
   string left = myProperties.get(PropType::Controller_Left);
   string right = myProperties.get(PropType::Controller_Right);
+  Controller::Type leftType = Controller::getType(left);
+  Controller::Type rightType = Controller::getType(right);
   try
   {
     ByteBuffer image;
@@ -145,10 +147,10 @@ void RomInfoWidget::parseProperties(const FilesystemNode& node)
     if(node.exists() && !node.isDirectory() &&
       (image = instance().openROM(node, md5, size)) != nullptr)
     {
-      left = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, left,
+      left = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, leftType,
           !swappedPorts ? Controller::Jack::Left : Controller::Jack::Right,
           instance().settings());
-      right = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, right,
+      right = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, rightType,
           !swappedPorts ? Controller::Jack::Right : Controller::Jack::Left,
           instance().settings());
     }

src/gui/StellaSettingsDialog.cxx

@@ -187,7 +187,7 @@ void StellaSettingsDialog::addGameOptions(WidgetArray& wid, int& xpos, int& ypos
   int pwidth = font.getStringWidth("Sega Genesis");
   myLeftPortLabel = new StaticTextWidget(this, font, xpos, ypos + 1, "Left port  ");
   myLeftPort = new PopUpWidget(this, font, myLeftPortLabel->getRight(),
-    myLeftPortLabel->getTop() - 1, pwidth, lineHeight, ctrls, "");
+    myLeftPortLabel->getTop() - 1, pwidth, lineHeight, ctrls, "", 0, kLeftCChanged);
   wid.push_back(myLeftPort);
   ypos += lineHeight + VGAP;
 
@@ -197,7 +197,7 @@ void StellaSettingsDialog::addGameOptions(WidgetArray& wid, int& xpos, int& ypos
 
   myRightPortLabel = new StaticTextWidget(this, font, xpos, ypos + 1, "Right port ");
   myRightPort = new PopUpWidget(this, font, myRightPortLabel->getRight(),
-    myRightPortLabel->getTop() - 1, pwidth, lineHeight, ctrls, "");
+    myRightPortLabel->getTop() - 1, pwidth, lineHeight, ctrls, "", 0, kRightCChanged);
   wid.push_back(myRightPort);
   ypos += lineHeight + VGAP;
   myRightPortDetected = new StaticTextWidget(this, ifont, myRightPort->getLeft(), ypos,
@@ -371,6 +371,11 @@ void StellaSettingsDialog::handleCommand(CommandSender* sender, int cmd,
       handleOverscanChange();
       break;
 
+    case kLeftCChanged:
+    case kRightCChanged:
+      updateControllerStates();
+      break;
+
     default:
       Dialog::handleCommand(sender, cmd, data, 0);
       break;
@@ -441,49 +446,12 @@ void StellaSettingsDialog::loadControllerProperties(const Properties& props)
 
   if (enable)
   {
-    bool autoDetect = false;
-    ByteBuffer image;
-    string md5 = props.get(PropType::Cart_MD5);
-    uInt32 size = 0;
-    const FilesystemNode& node = FilesystemNode(instance().launcher().selectedRom());
-
-    // try to load the image for auto detection
-    if (!instance().hasConsole() &&
-      node.exists() && !node.isDirectory() && (image = instance().openROM(node, md5, size)) != nullptr)
-      autoDetect = true;
-
-    string label = "";
     string controller = props.get(PropType::Controller_Left);
-    bool swapPorts = props.get(PropType::Console_SwapPorts) == "YES";
-
     myLeftPort->setSelected(controller, "AUTO");
-    if (myLeftPort->getSelectedTag().toString() == "AUTO")
-    {
-      if (instance().hasConsole())
-        label = (!swapPorts ? instance().console().leftController().name()
-          : instance().console().rightController().name()) + " detected";
-      else if (autoDetect)
-        label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, controller,
-          !swapPorts ? Controller::Jack::Left : Controller::Jack::Right,
-          instance().settings()) + " detected";
-    }
-    myLeftPortDetected->setLabel(label);
-
-    label = "";
     controller = props.get(PropType::Controller_Right);
-
     myRightPort->setSelected(controller, "AUTO");
-    if (myRightPort->getSelectedTag().toString() == "AUTO")
+
-    {
+    updateControllerStates();
-      if (instance().hasConsole())
-        label = (!swapPorts ? instance().console().rightController().name()
-          : instance().console().leftController().name()) + " detected";
-      else if (autoDetect)
-        label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, controller,
-          !swapPorts ? Controller::Jack::Right : Controller::Jack::Left,
-          instance().settings()) + " detected";
-    }
-    myRightPortDetected->setLabel(label);
   }
   else
   {
@@ -529,3 +497,56 @@ void StellaSettingsDialog::openHelp()
   #endif
   myHelpDialog->open();
 }
+
+// - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
+void StellaSettingsDialog::updateControllerStates()
+{
+  bool autoDetect = false;
+  ByteBuffer image;
+  string md5 = myGameProperties.get(PropType::Cart_MD5);
+  uInt32 size = 0;
+
+  // try to load the image for auto detection
+  if(!instance().hasConsole())
+  {
+    const FilesystemNode& node = FilesystemNode(instance().launcher().selectedRom());
+
+    autoDetect = node.exists() && !node.isDirectory() && (image = instance().openROM(node, md5, size)) != nullptr;
+  }
+  string label = "";
+  Controller::Type type = Controller::getType(myLeftPort->getSelectedTag().toString());
+
+  if(type == Controller::Type::Unknown)
+  {
+    if(instance().hasConsole())
+      label = (instance().console().leftController().name()) + " detected";
+    else if(autoDetect)
+      label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, type,
+                                             Controller::Jack::Left,
+                                             instance().settings()) + " detected";
+  }
+  myLeftPortDetected->setLabel(label);
+
+  label = "";
+  type = Controller::getType(myRightPort->getSelectedTag().toString());
+
+  if(type == Controller::Type::Unknown)
+  {
+    if(instance().hasConsole())
+      label = (instance().console().rightController().name()) + " detected";
+    else if(autoDetect)
+      label = ControllerDetector::detectName(image.get(), size, type,
+                                             Controller::Jack::Right,
+                                             instance().settings()) + " detected";
+  }
+  myRightPortDetected->setLabel(label);
+
+  // Compumate bankswitching scheme doesn't allow to select controllers
+  bool enableSelectControl = myGameProperties.get(PropType::Cart_Type) != "CM";
+
+  myLeftPortLabel->setEnabled(enableSelectControl);
+  myRightPortLabel->setEnabled(enableSelectControl);
+  myLeftPort->setEnabled(enableSelectControl);
+  myRightPort->setEnabled(enableSelectControl);
+}
+

src/gui/StellaSettingsDialog.hxx

@@ -66,6 +66,8 @@ class StellaSettingsDialog : public Dialog
 
     void openHelp();
 
+    void updateControllerStates();
+
   private:
     // UI theme
     PopUpWidget*      myThemePopup;
@@ -109,7 +111,9 @@ class StellaSettingsDialog : public Dialog
       kHelp             = 'SShl',
       kScanlinesChanged = 'SSsc',
       kPhosphorChanged  = 'SSph',
-      kOverscanChanged  = 'SSov'
+      kOverscanChanged  = 'SSov',
+      kLeftCChanged     = 'LCch',
+      kRightCChanged    = 'RCch',
     };
 
     // Game properties for currently loaded ROM