diff --git a/src/core/fullscreen_ui.cpp b/src/core/fullscreen_ui.cpp
index bd0fd38ae..3a5840207 100644
--- a/src/core/fullscreen_ui.cpp
+++ b/src/core/fullscreen_ui.cpp
@@ -4682,7 +4682,9 @@ void FullscreenUI::DrawGraphicsSettingsPage()
   DrawToggleSetting(
     bsi, FSUI_ICONSTR(ICON_FA_FILE, "Dump Replaced Textures"),
     FSUI_CSTR("Dumps textures that have replacements already loaded."), "TextureReplacements", "DumpReplacedTextures",
-    false, texture_cache_enabled && GetEffectiveBoolSetting(bsi, "TextureReplacements", "DumpTextures", false));
+    false,
+    (texture_cache_enabled && GetEffectiveBoolSetting(bsi, "TextureReplacements", "DumpTextures", false)) ||
+      GetEffectiveBoolSetting(bsi, "TextureReplacements", "DumpVRAMWrites", false));
 
   DrawToggleSetting(bsi, FSUI_ICONSTR(ICON_FA_FILE_ALT, "Enable VRAM Write Replacement"),
                     FSUI_CSTR("Enables the replacement of background textures in supported games."),
diff --git a/src/core/gpu_hw_texture_cache.cpp b/src/core/gpu_hw_texture_cache.cpp
index 8dbf665ef..81004ca78 100644
--- a/src/core/gpu_hw_texture_cache.cpp
+++ b/src/core/gpu_hw_texture_cache.cpp
@@ -305,7 +305,7 @@ static std::string GetTextureReplacementDirectory();
 static std::string GetTextureDumpDirectory();
 
 static VRAMReplacementName GetVRAMWriteHash(u32 width, u32 height, const void* pixels);
-static std::string GetVRAMWriteDumpFilename(const VRAMReplacementName& name);
+static std::string GetVRAMWriteDumpPath(const VRAMReplacementName& name);
 
 static bool IsMatchingReplacementPalette(HashType full_palette_hash, GPUTextureMode mode, GPUTexturePaletteReg palette,
                                          const TextureReplacementName& name);
@@ -812,6 +812,7 @@ void GPUTextureCache::Shutdown()
   s_state.vram_write_texture_replacements.clear();
   s_state.texture_page_texture_replacements.clear();
   s_state.dumped_textures.clear();
+  s_state.dumped_vram_writes.clear();
 }
 
 void GPUTextureCache::SetHashCacheTextureFormat()
@@ -2689,8 +2690,15 @@ void GPUTextureCache::DumpVRAMWrite(u32 width, u32 height, const void* pixels)
 
   s_state.dumped_vram_writes.insert(name);
 
-  const std::string filename = GetVRAMWriteDumpFilename(name);
-  if (filename.empty() || FileSystem::FileExists(filename.c_str()))
+  if (!g_gpu_settings.texture_replacements.dump_replaced_textures &&
+      s_state.vram_replacements.find(name) != s_state.vram_replacements.end())
+  {
+    INFO_LOG("Not dumping VRAM write '{}' because it already has a replacement", name.ToString());
+    return;
+  }
+
+  const std::string path = GetVRAMWriteDumpPath(name);
+  if (path.empty() || FileSystem::FileExists(path.c_str()))
     return;
 
   Image image(width, height, ImageFormat::RGBA8);
@@ -2711,9 +2719,14 @@ void GPUTextureCache::DumpVRAMWrite(u32 width, u32 height, const void* pixels)
   if (s_state.config.dump_vram_write_force_alpha_channel)
     image.SetAllPixelsOpaque();
 
-  INFO_LOG("Dumping {}x{} VRAM write to '{}'", width, height, Path::GetFileName(filename));
-  if (!image.SaveToFile(filename.c_str())) [[unlikely]]
-    ERROR_LOG("Failed to dump {}x{} VRAM write to '{}'", width, height, filename);
+  INFO_LOG("Dumping {}x{} VRAM write to '{}'", width, height, Path::GetFileName(path));
+
+  Error error;
+  if (!image.SaveToFile(path.c_str(), Image::DEFAULT_SAVE_QUALITY, &error)) [[unlikely]]
+  {
+    ERROR_LOG("Failed to dump {}x{} VRAM write to '{}': {}", width, height, Path::GetFileName(path),
+              error.GetDescription());
+  }
 }
 
 void GPUTextureCache::DumpTexture(TextureReplacementType type, u32 offset_x, u32 offset_y, u32 src_width,
@@ -3390,7 +3403,7 @@ GPUTextureCache::VRAMReplacementName GPUTextureCache::GetVRAMWriteHash(u32 width
   return {hash.low64, hash.high64};
 }
 
-std::string GPUTextureCache::GetVRAMWriteDumpFilename(const VRAMReplacementName& name)
+std::string GPUTextureCache::GetVRAMWriteDumpPath(const VRAMReplacementName& name)
 {
   std::string ret;
   if (!EnsureGameDirectoryExists())
diff --git a/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.cpp b/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.cpp
index ec5eedb04..f651e0500 100644
--- a/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.cpp
+++ b/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.cpp
@@ -289,9 +289,11 @@ GraphicsSettingsWidget::GraphicsSettingsWidget(SettingsWindow* dialog, QWidget*
   connect(m_ui.enableTextureReplacements, &QCheckBox::checkStateChanged, this,
           &GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableAnyTextureReplacementsChanged);
   connect(m_ui.enableTextureDumping, &QCheckBox::checkStateChanged, this,
-          &GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableTextureDumpingChanged);
+          &GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableAnyTextureDumpingChanged);
   connect(m_ui.vramWriteReplacement, &QCheckBox::checkStateChanged, this,
           &GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableAnyTextureReplacementsChanged);
+  connect(m_ui.vramWriteDumping, &QCheckBox::checkStateChanged, this,
+          &GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableAnyTextureDumpingChanged);
   connect(m_ui.textureReplacementOptions, &QPushButton::clicked, this,
           &GraphicsSettingsWidget::onTextureReplacementOptionsClicked);
 
@@ -1169,16 +1171,19 @@ void GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableTextureCacheChanged()
   m_ui.enableTextureReplacements->setEnabled(tc_enabled);
   m_ui.enableTextureDumping->setEnabled(tc_enabled);
   m_ui.alwaysTrackUploads->setEnabled(tc_enabled);
-  onEnableTextureDumpingChanged();
+  onEnableAnyTextureDumpingChanged();
   onEnableAnyTextureReplacementsChanged();
 }
 
-void GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableTextureDumpingChanged()
+void GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableAnyTextureDumpingChanged()
 {
   const bool tc_enabled = m_dialog->getEffectiveBoolValue("GPU", "EnableTextureCache", false);
   const bool dumping_enabled =
-    tc_enabled && m_dialog->getEffectiveBoolValue("TextureReplacements", "DumpTextures", false);
-  m_ui.dumpReplacedTextures->setEnabled(dumping_enabled);
+    (tc_enabled && m_dialog->getEffectiveBoolValue("TextureReplacements", "DumpTextures", false));
+  const bool background_dumping_enabled =
+    m_dialog->getEffectiveBoolValue("TextureReplacements", "DumpVRAMWrites", false);
+  const bool any_dumping_enabled = (dumping_enabled || background_dumping_enabled);
+  m_ui.dumpReplacedTextures->setEnabled(any_dumping_enabled);
 }
 
 void GraphicsSettingsWidget::onEnableAnyTextureReplacementsChanged()
diff --git a/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.h b/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.h
index d1ae58060..f86913901 100644
--- a/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.h
+++ b/src/duckstation-qt/graphicssettingswidget.h
@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ private Q_SLOTS:
   void onMediaCaptureAudioEnabledChanged();
 
   void onEnableTextureCacheChanged();
-  void onEnableTextureDumpingChanged();
+  void onEnableAnyTextureDumpingChanged();
   void onEnableAnyTextureReplacementsChanged();
   void onTextureReplacementOptionsClicked();